Home

John's Q&As
ConnectEd’s Gary Hoachlander on high schools of the future
 
 

Recent Videos
ConnectEd’...
Chuck Weis on la...
Ze’ev Wurm...
State Superinten...
More videos
 
 

Few low-income districts pass parcel taxes

Posted in Uncategorized

Parcel taxes are one of the few ways that cash-strapped school districts can raise money for schools. Few districts try, in part because it takes a two-thirds majority of voters to pass one. And most often, it’s wealthy communities that succeed.

In its report, Educational Opportunities in Hard Times, UCLA’s Institute of Demcracy, Education and Access looked at the 29 districts that put a parcel tax on the ballot last year. In the 20 districts that passed a parcel tax, the average percentage of students receiving free or reduced price lunches — a measure of poverty — was 15 percent. In the nine districts in which the parcel tax lost, an average of 56 percent of students received free or reduced lunches. In not one of the districts that passed a parcel tax was the average percentage of students received free or reduced lunches above 40 percent.

Parcel taxes are a desperate source of revenue for school districts. But they’re not a solution for low-income communities — at least not in their current form.


By John Fensterwald on January 21st, 2010

Comments on Few low-income districts pass parcel taxes

Tuyet: just to make clear, a parcel tax is a uniform amount that all homeowners pay, regardless of the property's valuation. So owners of expensive and most homes, as well as commercial property owners, pay the same amount (an inequity imposed by Prop 13). Most districts have passed modest parcel taxes between $50 and $500 (the latter in rich communities), usually for a set period (five or seven years most often) and for a specific purpose. They can include a yearly inflation factor, but most don't. RDT: Thanks for the examples. You are right. In other years, some districts with large numbers of low-income families have passed parcel taxes, including some in my backyard (Alum Rock comes to mind). But the IDEA analysis is useful, if only for one year's data. I didn't mention SCA6, which would lower the threshold to 55 percent. So far, Sen. Joe Simitian can't find one Republican vote needed for Senate passage.
- John Fensterwald
For that school district that is thinking of having parcel tax. They should think two and listen to homeowners’ perspective of the area before they put any parcel tax on their district especially the poor school district. I just buy a home last year in a poor school district 2. My parcel tax for that school district is $1700 something for year. And it is compound 3% each year and if I ever live there for 30 years it will go up to $5000 something. That is just for school district 2 parcel tax not included other part of property tax. For a $200000, I am ending up pay almost double mortgage $10,000 or more for property tax itself. No wonder why homeowners don’t want to pass parcel tax. You, school district kill all good homeowners in your district and make them want to buy their house in a different the area that do not have parcel tax or a very low parcel tax. The Parcel tax will create other housing problems in the near future when the parcel tax go up so high and homeowner can not pay anymore. Who is going to lose out again not only the homeowner but also the school too? Just ask your school this question if you are the homeowner of your area would you want to live in an area that have so high parcel tax that you can not pay.
- Tuyet Truong
Going only slightly further back, there are some local counter examples. Live Oak (44.6% Free/Reduced Lunch) passed a parcel tax in 2008 with 77% of the vote, and the Santa Cruz Elementary District passed one with an 80% yes vote. In the parcel tax campaigns I've worked on the conventional wisdom is that poorer neighborhoods will be more supportive than more affluent ones, and I think the precinct by precinct counts would bear that out. So I think the dynamic is something more complex than that poor communities aren't willing to pay higher taxes -- possibly that with the 2/3 threshold, successful "yes" campaigns are expensive.
- RDT
 
Return to Home page

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Get updates of The Educated Guess

Enter your email address:
 

About The Educated Guess
The Educated Guess is a forum on education policies in California and Silicon Valley. It is funded by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation and sponsored by the Silicon Valley E
Read more
 

About John
John Fensterwald is a journalist at the Silicon Valley Education Foundation,
which he joined in September 2009. For 11 years before that, he wrote editorials at the Mercury News in San Jose, with a focus on education.
Read more
 

Recent Posts
 

Archives
 

Categories
 

Other Links
  • Bridging Differences Diane Ravitch and Deborah Meyer, opposites on some issue, share an insightful dialogue.
  • California Progress Report Check out author and retired newspaper editor Peter Schrag’s column every Monday.
  • California Teachers Association The teachers union’s perspective on ed reform and issues affecting teachers
  • EdSource Prime site for facts and research on education in California.
  • Education Next Online journal and blogs sponsored by Hoover Institution’s Koret Task Force on K-12 Education
  • Edutopia “What works in public education. Funded by The George Lucas Educational Foundation
  • Eduwonk Blog by Andrew Rotherham, co-founder and Publisher of Education Sector, keeps sharp eye on national scene.
  • EdVoice Small advocacy group that’s a power behind the scenes in Sacramento.
  • Enterprise Blog Andrew Smarick keeps a close eye on federal spending. He writes for the conservative American Enterprise Institute.
  • Getting Down To Facts studies 20 studies on school governance and finance; published in 2007. Encyclopedic and relevant.
  • Governor’s Committee on Education Excellence 2007 report with recommendations the governor shouldn’t have ignored.
  • Joanne Jacobs Former colleage at the Mercury News challenges assumptions with incisive writing.
  • Learning Matters John Merrow, PBS’ education correspondent
  • The College Puzzle Stanford Professor Emeritus of Education and Business Administration Michael Kirst explores policy issues relating to the preparation for and success in college.