Home

John's Q&As

ConnectEd’s Gary Hoachlander on high schools of the future
 
 

Recent Videos

ConnectEd’...
Chuck Weis on la...
Ze’ev Wurm...
State Superinten...
More videos
 
 

Rae Belisle leaving EdVoice

Posted in Advocacy organizations

Rae Belisle,  a savvy advocate for change as well as an influential Sacramento insider with the governor’s ear, has resigned as president and CEO of EdVoice, and her bid for a full term on the State Board of Education is in trouble. Her departure from both EdVoice and the board would leave low-income and minority children with one less  strong voice.

Belisle submitted her resignation for health reasons to the non-profit EdVoice board in January, though she  had not made that public until now. Her last day at work is March 1.

Belisle has been taking medication for breast cancer, which is in remission.  She says she stopped the medicine for two months while helping with the state’s Race to the Top application. When she resumed taking it, the side effects were worse.

Her term on the State Board of Education expires March 11. Senate President Pro Tem Darrell Steinberg canceled a scheduled hearing Wednesday before the Senate Rules Committee amid rumors that Belisle would resign, or the governor would withdraw her nomination. She said Sunday that neither case was true and that she would meet Tuesday with Schwarzenegger’s advisers. Another board member for the past year who also was to have a hearing Wednesday, Jorge Lopez, executive director of Oakland Charter Academy, resigned last week.

Belisle, 54, has been at EdVoice, a non-profit that works to eliminate education inequality,  for two years. A year ago, Gov. Schwarzenegger appointed her to the state board to finish the term of the late philanthropist and charter school financier  Don Fisher.  In those rolls and her capacity, before that, as chair of the Charter School Advisory Commission,  she became identified with controversial school reforms of the past several years: an open enrollment law allowing interdistrict transfers for students in low-performing schools; statewide charter approvals for high-performing charter organizations, and  a policy, now challenged in court, of requiring Algebra I for nearly all eighth graders.

That – and her defense of Proposition 227, requiring instruction of English only, as counsel to the state board – have made her many adversaries. The California School Boards Assn. (see opposition letter), the Association of California School Administrators, bilingual organizations and the California Federation of Teachers, all oppose her nomination. However, the California Teachers Assn., the largest teachers union, has not taken a position, and she has the support of a number of groups representing minority students. CSU Chancellor Charles Reed also endorsed her for her work promoting the Early Assessment Program for prospective CSU students.

Belisle said  that Steinberg would not give his support for her nomination, although a spokeswoman for Steinberg declined to comment. State board candidates need a two-thirds majority of the Senate for confirmation – a difficult threshold, especially when you’re as outspoken and forceful as she is.

Belisle said her future plans were uncertain, although she said she would continue as a policy advocate and an informal adviser to EdVoice.

Comments on Rae Belisle leaving EdVoice

Oh come on - she is a menace. Her actions are those of person who distains poor and minority kids, rather than caring for them as she claims at every turn. This is only one of the many terrible appointments made by this governor and for once the Senate (and Steinberg) are bucking up.
- Nell Bless
I am sorry to read of Ms. Belisle's health issues. I am not sorry to read she is leaving the CA SBE. Having attended thae last half-dozen SBE meetings I was always amazed at the superficial knowledge of education she exhibited. More telling was her ideological lack of flexiblity that led to two lawsuits. I recall the meeting the SBE was considering Ed Code waivers. She asked how the SBE had voted before, and was informed that waivers were granted based on case by case need. At this point she said (and this is pretty close to a quote): "I believe the SBE should be consistent, even if it's consistently wrong." When the attendees laughed she obviously had no idea why. Ed Voice will always be able to find another corporate shill or educational no-nothing to be its CEO.
- Gary Ravani
The real sin for which Mrs. Belisle is punished is her unique effectiveness. Effectiveness in advocating for the disadvantaged so they can escape failing schools; effectiveness in giving immigrant and non-immigrant Latinos the gift of English, rather than have them stuck in mindless bilingual classes from Kindergarten until they graduate; effectiveness in promoting essential standards so that disadvantaged kids will not graduate with a meaningless diploma that will lead them nowhere. Now Steinberg prefers to kill the best thing that happened to HIS OWN constituents, rather than to stand up to racial politicos that prefer their voters never to learn English, and to teacher unions that instinctively hate anything that smacks of accountability or of giving options to the public. For shame.
- Ze’ev Wurman
We are losing one of the greats in education. Steinberg should be voted out of office as soon as possible for his political stunt. Playing games with California's children should not be tolerated.
- Veronica Norris
 
Return to Home page

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Get updates of The Educated Guess

Enter your email address:

 

About The Educated Guess

The Educated Guess is a forum on education policies in California and Silicon Valley. It is funded by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation and sponsored by the Silicon Valley E
Read more
 

About John

John Fensterwald is a journalist at the Silicon Valley Education Foundation,
which he joined in September 2009. For 11 years before that, he wrote editorials at the Mercury News in San Jose, with a focus on education.
Read more
 

Recent Posts

 

Archives

 

Categories

 

Other Links

  • Bridging Differences Diane Ravitch and Deborah Meyer, opposites on some issue, share an insightful dialogue.
  • California Progress Report Check out author and retired newspaper editor Peter Schrag’s column every Monday.
  • California Teachers Association The teachers union’s perspective on ed reform and issues affecting teachers
  • EdSource Prime site for facts and research on education in California.
  • Education Next Online journal and blogs sponsored by Hoover Institution’s Koret Task Force on K-12 Education
  • Edutopia “What works in public education. Funded by The George Lucas Educational Foundation
  • Eduwonk Blog by Andrew Rotherham, co-founder and Publisher of Education Sector, keeps sharp eye on national scene.
  • EdVoice Small advocacy group that’s a power behind the scenes in Sacramento.
  • Enterprise Blog Andrew Smarick keeps a close eye on federal spending. He writes for the conservative American Enterprise Institute.
  • Getting Down To Facts studies 20 studies on school governance and finance; published in 2007. Encyclopedic and relevant.
  • Governor’s Committee on Education Excellence 2007 report with recommendations the governor shouldn’t have ignored.
  • Joanne Jacobs Former colleage at the Mercury News challenges assumptions with incisive writing.
  • Learning Matters John Merrow, PBS’ education correspondent
  • The College Puzzle Stanford Professor Emeritus of Education and Business Administration Michael Kirst explores policy issues relating to the preparation for and success in college.