Home

John's Q&As

State Superintendent Jack O’Connell looks back – and ahead
 
 

Recent Videos

State Superinten...
Derek Mitchell, ...
Stephanie Couch ...
Foothill College...
More videos
 
 

Worth hearing and reading

Posted in Achievement Gap, Charters, Teacher Development

A few noteworthy articles and announcements that have come to my attention:

KQED Forum to explore college issues

Tune in KQED radio’s Forum at 9 a.m. Wednesday for a two-hour exploration of issues faced by first-generation college students and their families. Host Michael Krasny will  broadcast live from Downtown College Prep in San Jose, the first charter school in Santa Clara County and a 10-year successful partnership between the school and San Jose Unified. The largely Hispanic school recruits students who aspire to college but have not done well in middle school and prepares them for a four-year college.

Panelists will include Michael Kirst, Stanford emeritus education professor, writer and an authority on the transition between high school and colllege,  Downtown College Prep founder and executive director Jennifer Andaluz, principal Michael DeSouza, counselors from James Lick High in East San Jose and from Santa Clara University, as well as graduates of the charter school.

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Worth hearing and reading

Not sure that she burned and detonated. As she tells it, they urged her to stay and argue with them. ...
- Reader
I've been following the reaction to Ravitch's book closely, and it actually sounds to me like her right-wing ex-comrades are ...
- CarolineSF
Thanks for the update. Looks like she burned and detonated the bridge on the way out.
- John Fensterwald
"Peterson and Ravitch serve together on Hoover’s Koret Task Force on K-12 Education." "Served" is the right tense. Ravitch left Koret ...
- Ze’ev Wurman
 

Full Circle Fund’s Rx for schools

Posted in Education Excellence Committee, Revenue and taxes, Student spending, Teacher Development

Members of the Full Circle Fund, a Bay Area philanthropy made up of socially active leaders and entrepreneurs, has joined the call for giving school districts more autonomy and taxing authority.

Granting local voters the power to pass a limited surcharge of the property tax rate  is one policy recommendation of “EACH: A Vision for California’s Future.” The 11-page policy platform is the product of nine months of work by the 60-member Education Circle, one of four study groups within the Full Circle Fund.

A property surcharge would directly challenge of the limits imposed by Proposition 13.  It also could create equity problems – and likely lead to a lawsuit ­– since rich communities would more readily pass such a measure. So the Education Circle also urges establishing a state matching fund as an incentive for  low-wealth communities to raise revenue. The platform also urges bringing up California’s level of funding to the “national norm” and includes a useful graph  that compares states’  per student spending relative to its teachers’ salaries.

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Full Circle Fund’s Rx for schools

Be the first to comment on Full Circle Fund’s Rx for schools.

Stimulus law’s futile goal of reform

Posted in Race to the Top, Teacher Development

In directing $80 billion in stimulus dollars over two years to the nation’s elementary and secondary schools, the Obama administration made a big deal about tying the money to school reform. States were required to make four assurances in accepting the money, including, most importantly, a commitment to make progress in producing more effective teachers and seeing that they are equitably distributed in low-income schools.

But those assurances, it turns out, were vague and unenforceable. California got 90 percent of the money without having to tell the feds what steps it planned to take, and the Obama administration had no way to hold it accountable anyway.

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Stimulus law’s futile goal of reform

this is the wonderful article you have wrote it is very informative thanks for giving the updates
- stainless steel metal hoses
(So says my sister-in-law from Ohio.)
- John Fensterwald
Johnny Your woderful article is frought with frustrating analysis of the gov`s failure to provide leadership for positive change in ...
- Barb
 

Hot off the press

Posted in Teacher Development, Uncategorized

Here’s some provocative reading to ruin  – no, enrich – your long weekend in between watching the Nordic combined and the biathlon.

Texas rules: Size matters when it comes to textbooks. I’m talking about the population of states that buy them, not the tonnage of the tomes that middle schoolers carry on their backs.

California is big enough to push its weight around with textbook publishers and control its autonomy. But pity small states that are prey to the looney dictates of the self-righteous majority  on the Texas State Board of Education.

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Hot off the press

A sentence like this, promoting a snarky, contemptuous headline like this, has destructive power: "The subtitle, “why firing the desk-sleepers, ...
- CarolineSF
I'd say that's wildly exaggerated, defensive reaction to "the media" - whoever they are. It's certainly an unfair ...
- John Fensterwald
This is a quote from Sharon Higgins, who runs the Perimeter Primate blog and is a veteran Oakland public school ...
- CarolineSF
I'm in my 25th kid-year as an involved urban public-school parent (which means I have vastly more contact than most ...
- CarolineSF
Caroline, The issue is not privacy of the teachers; it is a system so dense with due-process rights that the ...
- John Fensterwald
John, the parent leader I refer to asked me that same question -- are the departed employees still working in ...
- CarolineSF
Was it so discreet that these teachers are now working in other schools in the district -- another round in ...
- John Fensterwald
I still have trouble understanding why states don't pay the best teachers, scholars and curriculum developers in the country to ...
- Martha Kanter
True enough, John! One other comment. An influential parent leader in SF whose child is in my daughter's class commented ...
- CarolineSF
Caroline: We certainly have found an area of agreement: bad decision-making by management at our previous employer.
- John Fensterwald
I'm in my fifth year (second kid) as a parent at an urban high school. Among many fine teachers, the ...
- carolineSF
 

Tenure not quite automatic in L.A.

Posted in Teacher Development

Embarrassed by a Los Angeles Times story revealing teacher tenure has been all but automatic in Los Angeles Unified, the district is tripling the number of probationary teachers who will be fired this year.

The extra scrutiny will help weed out bad teachers before they gain due process rights that make it very difficult to fire teachers for poor performance. But L.A. Unified’s ability to identify effective teachers is still hampered, as in many districts, by a poor evaluation process and a problematic, two-year probationary period. The district is in the process of changing the former, but only the Legislature or voters can fix the latter.

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Tenure not quite automatic in L.A.

To add some more history, the probationary period was reduced from three to two years as part of SB813 in ...
- Mary Bergan
That some penance, John.
- John Fensterwald
John You should know better. The laws of California, signed by the republican governor in office in ...
- john mockler
 

Seven years later, teacher ordered to be fired

Tags: , ,
Posted in Teacher Development

In a notable break from the past, the president of the nation’s second largest teachers union has committed to changing laws that drag out procedures for firing teachers charged with incompetence or misconduct.

On Tuesday, the same day that American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten made that promise in a Washington, D.C., speech, a Superior Court judge in Los Angeles ordered the immediate firing of an LA Unified teacher whose case offers the most egregious example of  what needs fixing. 

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Seven years later, teacher ordered to be fired

Governor targets seniority protections

Tags: ,
Posted in Teacher Development

Four years ago, Gov. Schwarzenegger failed to persuade voters to change the tenure laws for teachers. But that hasn’t deterred him from pushing again in his final year in office.

In his budget message, the governor said he’d propose eliminating the law requiring that teacher layoffs and reassignments be done strictly on the basis  of seniority. He also wants school boards, not the Commission on Professional  Competence, to have the final say on teacher firings. (Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Governor targets seniority protections

I was a parent on a teacher hiring committee, and I just laughed myself silly to see all those teacher ...
- elfling
[...] Fensterwald notes Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s effort to revamp the state’s teacher seniority rules, [...]
- Dropout Nation » Blog Archive » Read: Monday Morning Quarterback Edition
 

The give and the get from joining Race to the Top

Posted in Common Core standards, Race to the Top, Teacher Development

The triumvirate responsible for the state’s application to the Race to the Top made one last push Monday to persuade local districts to join in. But they’re giving the boards of trustees, local teachers unions and superintendents only until Jan. 8 – 3 ½ weeks from now – to sign a memorandum of understanding, and they are requesting a letter of intent by Dec. 31.

Even after reading a long letter from Superintendent Jack O’Connell, State Board of Education President Ted Mitchell and Schwarzenegger’s secretary of education, Glen Thomas,  discussing likely elements of the state plan, district superintendents and charter school principals may still be wondering if there is a there there. The letter is light on details and heavy with flattery. (“Our state includes some of the most diverse and innovative school and district practices in the nation.”)

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on The give and the get from joining Race to the Top

My phrase, not the legislative definition. I am referring to the fourth alternative that the feds added to the final ...
- johnf
What is behind the phrase "adopting a catch-all transformation strategy"?
- Paul Muench
 

Race to Top bill would give parents more power

Posted in Charters, Race to the Top, STEM, Teacher Development

A majority of parents at a low-performing school could force a district trustees to turn it over to a charter school operator or take other dramatic actions, under an amendment that Sen. Gloria Romero has added to her Race to the Top legislation.

The Assembly Education Committee will take up a competing bill, ABX5-8, sponsored by Chairwoman Julia Brownley, and possibly Romero’s SBX5-1, tomorrow. Assembly leaders haven’t indicated  whether they’ll seriously consider Romero’s bill.

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Race to Top bill would give parents more power

Bill would expand who could grant a teaching credential

Posted in Common Core standards, Teacher Development

Jumping ahead of the expected release today of the Assembly’s version of Race to the Top legislation, Republican Assemblyman Brian Nestande of Palm Desert has introduced three bills of his own.

Two deal with alternative ways to bring teachers into the profession. The third would make it slightly easier to get rid of those who end up performing badly.

(Read more and comment on this post)

Comments on Bill would expand who could grant a teaching credential

It would be great if teacher credentialing would be simplified. But the unions won't allow it. Not only do you ...
- Natasha Wunderlich
Mike: I would think any change to the ed code dealing with teacher terminations would be DOA. ...
- johnf
Are these bills regarded as having any chance of being passed by the Legislature? It seems to me they are ...
- Mike Dunne
 
Return to Home page
 

Get updates of The Educated Guess

Enter your email address:

 

About The Educated Guess

The Educated Guess is a forum on education policies in California and Silicon Valley. It is funded by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation and sponsored by the Silicon Valley E
Read more
 

About John

John Fensterwald is a journalist at the Silicon Valley Education Foundation,
which he joined in September 2009. For 11 years before that, he wrote editorials at the Mercury News in San Jose, with a focus on education.
Read more
 

Recent Posts

 

Archives

 

Categories

 

Other Links

  • Bridging Differences Diane Ravitch and Deborah Meyer, opposites on some issue, share an insightful dialogue.
  • California Progress Report Check out author and retired newspaper editor Peter Schrag’s column every Monday.
  • California Teachers Association The teachers union’s perspective on ed reform and issues affecting teachers
  • EdSource Prime site for facts and research on education in California.
  • Education Next Online journal and blogs sponsored by Hoover Institution’s Koret Task Force on K-12 Education
  • Edutopia “What works in public education. Funded by The George Lucas Educational Foundation
  • Eduwonk Blog by Andrew Rotherham, co-founder and Publisher of Education Sector, keeps sharp eye on national scene.
  • EdVoice Small advocacy group that’s a power behind the scenes in Sacramento.
  • Enterprise Blog Andrew Smarick keeps a close eye on federal spending. He writes for the conservative American Enterprise Institute.
  • Getting Down To Facts studies 20 studies on school governance and finance; published in 2007. Encyclopedic and relevant.
  • Governor’s Committee on Education Excellence 2007 report with recommendations the governor shouldn’t have ignored.
  • Joanne Jacobs Former colleage at the Mercury News challenges assumptions with incisive writing.
  • Learning Matters John Merrow, PBS’ education correspondent
  • The College Puzzle Stanford Professor Emeritus of Education and Business Administration Michael Kirst explores policy issues relating to the preparation for and success in college.